A fiduciary, such as a registered investment adviser, owes you an ongoing duty of care and loyalty across the advisory relationship: to give advice in your best interest and to avoid or fully disclose conflicts. A broker is paid to execute transactions and recommend securities, and when advising retail customers must follow Regulation Best Interest, which applies at the time of each recommendation rather than as a continuing duty to monitor your account. The practical difference often comes down to how each is paid and whether anyone is responsible for your whole portfolio over time.

What a Fiduciary Is

Under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, registered investment advisers are fiduciaries to their clients. The duty has two parts:

  • Duty of care: give advice in the client’s best interest, based on a reasonable understanding of their goals, seek best execution of trades, and monitor the relationship over its agreed scope.
  • Duty of loyalty: do not put the adviser’s interests ahead of the client’s, and make full and fair disclosure of conflicts.

Advisers are typically paid fees for advice, such as a flat fee, a retainer or a percentage of assets.

What a Broker Is

A broker, or registered representative of a broker-dealer, buys and sells securities for customers and makes recommendations. Brokers are usually paid through commissions, markups or other transaction-based compensation. Since 2020, brokers making recommendations to retail customers must comply with Regulation Best Interest, which requires them to act in the customer’s best interest at the time of the recommendation and to disclose and manage conflicts.

Fiduciary vs. Broker: The Key Differences

  • Scope of duty: an adviser’s fiduciary duty covers the whole advisory relationship; Reg BI applies to each recommendation.
  • Ongoing monitoring: advisers generally monitor accounts as agreed; brokers generally have no ongoing duty to monitor unless they agree to.
  • Compensation: advisers usually charge fees for advice; brokers are usually paid per transaction or product.
  • Typical conflicts: brokers may be paid more for some products than others; advisers’ conflicts often relate to asset-based fees, affiliates or proprietary products.
  • Disclosure documents: advisers file Form ADV; both deliver Form CRS to retail investors.

Why Dual Registration Complicates Things

Many professionals are both investment adviser representatives and registered brokers, and many firms are both advisers and broker-dealers. The same person may act as a fiduciary when managing your advisory account and as a broker when selling you an annuity or a product in a brokerage account. Ask which role applies to each recommendation, and look the person up on both adviserinfo.sec.gov and FINRA BrokerCheck.

Is a Financial Advisor a Fiduciary?

Not necessarily. “Financial advisor” is a general title, not a legal category. A person using it may be an investment adviser, a broker, an insurance agent, or a combination. The registration, not the title, tells you the standard.

Questions to Ask

  • Are you a registered investment adviser, a broker, or both?
  • Will you act as a fiduciary on every service you provide to me, and will you put that in writing?
  • How are you paid for each type of recommendation?
  • Who is responsible for monitoring my accounts over time?

How WE Family Offices Approaches Fiduciary Advice

WE Family Offices was founded by advisors who felt conflicted working in business models focused on selling financial products and services. The firm was built to offer families something different.

We are paid by our clients and only by them, and we receive no commissions or incentives from any manager, service provider or financial firm. We are non-discretionary, which removes sales-based compensation from the relationship and keeps families in control of their decisions. Our job is to help families understand their options and implement the ones that make the most sense for them, and our interests are aligned with the families we serve.

Sources