A non-discretionary advisory relationship is one where the advisor researches, recommends and helps implement, but the family approves every significant decision before it happens. The advisor cannot trade, hire or fire managers, or move money on its own authority. For families who want to stay in control of their wealth and understand how it is managed, it is often the better fit. For a direct comparison with discretionary management, see discretionary vs. non-discretionary investment management.

How a Non-Discretionary Relationship Works Day to Day

  1. Set the framework. The family and advisor agree on goals, risk tolerance, liquidity needs and an investment policy statement.
  2. Recommend. The advisor brings written recommendations, such as a rebalance, a new manager, a private commitment or a change in cash reserves, with the reasoning, risks, costs and alternatives.
  3. Decide. The family, or its investment committee, discusses and approves, modifies or declines.
  4. Implement. The advisor handles the paperwork and coordinates with custodians, managers and other providers.
  5. Monitor and report. Consolidated reporting shows results, fees and exposures, and the cycle repeats.

What the Family Does and Does Not Have to Do

The family’s job is to make decisions, not to run operations. Members review recommendations, ask questions and approve. They do not need to place trades, chase paperwork or coordinate providers; a good advisor does that. Families can choose how much detail they want, and the level of involvement can change over time or differ among family members.

Why Families Choose Non-Discretionary Advice

  • Control. Nothing significant happens without the family’s agreement.
  • Understanding. Each decision comes with an explanation, so the family learns how and why its portfolio is built.
  • Preparation of the next generation. Younger family members can join the discussions and learn by taking part.
  • Accountability. Written recommendations and recorded decisions make it easy to review advice later.
  • Fewer conflicts. When the advisor cannot act alone, there is less room for activity that benefits the advisor more than the family.

What to Expect From a Non-Discretionary Advisor

  • Clear, written recommendations with the costs and alternatives laid out
  • A predictable meeting schedule, plus a way to make time-sensitive decisions quickly
  • Full support with implementation after approval
  • Consolidated reporting across all accounts, managers and entities
  • Transparent compensation, disclosed in its Form ADV

Questions to Ask Before Choosing This Model

  • How are recommendations presented, and how much notice will we have?
  • What happens when a decision is needed between scheduled meetings?
  • Which tasks do you handle after we approve a decision?
  • How do you work with our existing banks and managers?
  • How are you paid, and by whom?

How WE Family Offices Works as a Non-Discretionary Advisor

We do not take discretion over our clients’ assets. Our model rests on the premise that families should be engaged in their Wealth Enterprise®: we help each family set its wealth management priorities and objectives, then execute on its behalf. Families can be as involved in the details as they like, while keeping authority over the critical decisions.

We also play an active role in execution, handling administrative tasks and supporting implementation of each family’s mandate. Families do not need to change banks or leave providers they value, and we are paid only by our clients, with no commissions or incentives from any manager or financial firm.

Sources