The difference between discretionary and non-discretionary investment management is who makes the final decision. In a discretionary arrangement, the client gives the advisor written authority to buy and sell investments without asking permission for each trade. In a non-discretionary arrangement, the advisor makes recommendations, but the client must approve each decision before anything happens.

Both are common, and both can be done well. The right choice depends on how involved the family wants to be, how quickly decisions need to be made, and how much the family wants to understand and own each decision.

What Discretionary Management Means

With discretionary management, the client signs an agreement, often called an investment management agreement or limited power of attorney, that lets the advisor trade in the account. The advisor still has to follow the client’s objectives, restrictions and investment policy, and it remains a fiduciary. But within those limits it can rebalance, change managers or securities, and respond to markets without contacting the client first. Investor.gov’s definition of a discretionary account describes the basic arrangement.

Advantages: speed, convenience and less time required from the family.
Trade-offs: the family may become a passive participant, may learn about decisions only after they are made, and may know less about why its portfolio is built the way it is.

What Non-Discretionary Management Means

In a non-discretionary relationship, the advisor researches, analyzes and recommends, and the family, or its investment committee, approves or declines. Once a decision is made, a good non-discretionary advisor does much of the work of carrying it out: paperwork, coordination with custodians and managers, and monitoring.

Advantages: the family keeps control, understands each decision and builds its own knowledge over time, which matters a great deal when the next generation takes over.
Trade-offs: decisions take a little longer, and the family needs a clear process for reviewing recommendations.

Discretionary vs. Non-Discretionary: Side by Side

  • Who decides: discretionary, the advisor within agreed limits; non-discretionary, the family.
  • Speed: discretionary is faster; non-discretionary adds an approval step.
  • Family involvement: discretionary can be minimal; non-discretionary keeps the family engaged.
  • Accountability: both arrangements involve a fiduciary adviser; in non-discretionary relationships the family also owns the final call.
  • Disclosure: advisers report whether they manage assets on a discretionary or non-discretionary basis in their Form ADV.

Does Non-Discretionary Mean More Work for the Family?

It does not have to. The family’s role is to make the important decisions, not to handle the administration. A well-run non-discretionary relationship has a regular meeting schedule, clear written recommendations, and an advisor that handles implementation once the family approves. Families can be as involved in the details as they like while keeping authority over the decisions that matter.

Hybrid Approaches

Some families combine the two. They might allow an outside manager discretion over a specific mandate, such as a bond portfolio, while keeping allocation, manager selection and major commitments as family decisions. The key is writing down clearly which decisions are delegated and which are not, usually in the investment policy statement.

How to Choose

  • How involved do family members want to be, now and in the next generation?
  • How quickly do decisions realistically need to be made?
  • Does the family have a process, such as an investment committee, to review recommendations?
  • How is the advisor paid, and could discretion over trading create any conflicts?
  • What will the advisor do to implement decisions once they are approved?

Why WE Family Offices Is a Non-Discretionary Advisor

We are non-discretionary advisors to all of our clients. Our advisory model is based on the belief that families should be active participants in their wealth: engaged, informed and in control of the critical decisions. We want to help manage a family’s wealth and also give the family the knowledge it needs to make decisions now and in the future.

That does not mean more work for the family. We help each family set its priorities and objectives, and then we execute on its behalf, handling administrative tasks and supporting implementation. Being non-discretionary also supports our broader approach: we are paid only by our clients, with no sales-based compensation, so our role is to advise, not to sell.

Sources